The following is a guest post by my good friend, Jessica Buttram.
Though we have disagreed in the past, she and I are united in our belief that food holidays should be treasured. As such, she felt compelled to write this post about the Thanksgiving Shaft. I couldn’t be prouder. This is my personal declaration of independence and I have printed it out and signed it SUCH is my support for it.
If you don’t know, check out Jessica’s blog here and my advice is to read as much of her now while you can, because very soon she will be writing books that will require real money to access her geniusness. So get to it. But AFTER you read her post.
_______________________
My list of Things That Piss Me Off is pretty short.
*Made-up English Words That Sound Like Real Words Therefore Causing Idiots To Use Them Particularly To Berate Others is pretty high up on that list.
*The (DAILY) Evening Ritual of Fighting With My Seven-Year-Old Over Bath Time is in the Top Five.
And I think we ALL know the Hierarchy of Doughnuts is pretty close to my heart.
But the most seasonally appropriate Thing That Pisses Me Off is, as the title suggests, The Thanksgiving Shaft.
This occurs when Americans (thanks to the help of Target and the Toys R Us toy catalog roughly the thickness of War and Peace and ABC Family with their generically Christmas movie special marathon) collectively forget about November and its existence for the sole purpose of one gluttonous, guilt-free Thursday. (And, if you are anything like me, Friday.) (Okay, and Saturday.) (But not the Sabbath, because gluttony is a sin.)
Here’s the deal. Retailers love Halloween. They go all out. As soon as they pull the Back-to-School supplies off the shelves, out come the orange and black and jack-o-lanterns and spooky displays. And why not? It’s a holiday that exists on the glorious foundation of demanding candy from strangers. I mean, come on, it’s the epitome of the American dream, right?
But then, November 1st happens and up on the rooftop the Christmas decorations come, and jingles playing over the radio and in elevators. I understand that there isn’t exactly a genre for Thanksgiving music, but…seriously? WHY NOT?
It’s sad, really. Thanksgiving had the bad fortune of being celebrated a measly month before Christmas. That’s like a child being born on December 26th.
No, worse than that. Thanksgiving is like the MIDDLE kid born on December 26th. It’s a double whammy.
Don’t get me wrong. I love Christmas just as much as the next person. Jesus is the reason for the season, okay? But when November 1st rolls around, and until the fourth Wednesday of the month, I want to be able to talk about my calorie-busting Turkey Day menu with appropriate drooling and NOT be asked what my Christmas plans are. Listen, Facebook friends, if you are legitimately asking whether it is too early to play Christmas music, the answer is yes. Without a doubt, for the love of green bean casserole, YES.
So on behalf of post-Christmas middle-child babies everywhere (Thanksgiving feels your pain, kids), this year, I’m giving Thanksgiving the attention it deserves. Internetually, that is, because I give it the attention it deserves every year. Right here. In my little pink heart. And stomach.
One day a year, you guys, we are allowed, nay, ENCOURAGED to stuff ourselves like a, well, Thanksgiving turkey. Forget the diets; gain a third of your body weight from one single meal. It’s cool, I promise. (Plus? It’s like a built-in New Year’s Resolution. Win win, America!)
Celebrate our founding fathers who didn’t die off thanks to cholera or cannibals and embrace the privilege of living in America by eating so much you have to wear elastic pants and are physically unable to move.
I mean, why do you think there’s an NFL game every year on Thanksgiving Day?
So we as Americans can park it on the couch under the pretense of “watching the game” while our stomachs struggle valiantly not to explode, stretching to the (approximate) size of hot air balloons and cutting off the blood flow to our legs, making it ACTUALLY impossible to do something like, oh I don’t know, walk to the kitchen for seconds. (There’s about a two-and-a-half hour window where you won’t want to push that second plate of turkey and stuffing. Trust me.)
And not to mention that tiny little detail of having a nationally sanctioned day of Giving Thanks. So the country is broke, and we should be worried about Asians and terrorists outsmarting us, and Jersey Shore is still on television, BUT…Wal-Mart will be open on Thanksgiving Day if you forget to buy cranberry sauce. So there’s that.
Oh, and there’s also the whole thing about civil rights, freedom of religion, the right to say whatever dumb crap comes out of our mouths, Modern Family and all-you-can-eat buffets.
This Thanksgiving, I’ll be sure to be extra thankful for my lovely family, my husband who is legitimately my best friend and doesn’t laugh too hard when I refer to myself as his Trophy Wife, the way my seven-year-old’s front tooth juts out because it’s juuuuuust about to fall out, how my seventeen-month-old girl says “I love you” by blowing me a kiss, and being present and aware and a witness to all the good and beautiful things that go unnoticed all the other days of the year.
And also for an extra helping of my dad’s phe-NOM-enal cornbread stuffing.
Seriously, guys. GET YOUR TURKEY-EATIN’ PANTS ON!
What’s your favorite Thanksgiving dish, and what are you thankful for? If you say anything about Christmas in the comments, I will break into your house and eat all your pie.









I disagree with 100% of this post. It's time to declare war on Thanksgiving. It's just a day. Christmas is a season. Its celebration should begin on November 1.
You can whip up vats of stuffing and mashed potatoes any day of the year. Christmas lights and trees need to be up for at least six weeks to make it worth hauling them out of the attic.
I'll admit, I have completely blurred the lines between Thanksgiving and Christmas and I lurv it that way.
I prefer to think of November and December as one great big ball of mushed up festivities. So yes, I may have started displaying my nativity scenes on Nov 4th of this year. But what can I say? I'm just so darn, borderline Jesus-jukey, thankful for Jesus. And I don't think he'll mind looking his little 8 lb 5oz baby eyes over my shoulder to observe my turkey eating later this month.
Once upon a time, I witnessed my dad hand-mix our secret cornbread stuffing recipe in one of those giant plastic bins people use to store ugly sweaters. It is THAT good.
OMG JESSICA WHY ARE YOU SO POLARIZING?
You're like the Lady Gaga of bloggers.
Sam brings up some solid points.
+ 65 points for "lurv"
I like Christmas; so sue me.
That being said, when should we show up at your house for Face Stuffing Stuffing Day?
Look. Thanksgiving is a day to be ACTIVELY aware of all our blessings. And eat stuff. Really good stuff. Stuff that takes me 7 hours to prepare. (Literally. I have a schedule of events.)
It should get its own season, too.
In our house, the Christmas tree goes up the day after Thanksgiving, and doesn't come down until New Year's. Sometimes later. (Okay…often later.) Just tack your six-week quota on at the end. Thanksgiving will thank you.
Hey! I like Christmas too. I just also like our perfect turkey drizzled with rosemary gravy and a small army of crescent rolls.
I don't want to worry about decorating my house or collecting Christmas lists while simultaneously trying to find the best recipe to deliciously incorporate sweet potatoes.
Oh, and Thanksgiving begins promptly at 2:00pm.
Don't think eating all your pie was an empty threat.
I'm even fond of sweet potato pie. Just a heads up.
I disagree with 100% of Sam's comment. It is NOT "just a day," and Christmas needs to cool it's jets and wait it's turn. Christmas is like a kid who goes to a friend's birthday party in June, and keeps saying, "My birthday is July 12th. My birthday is next month. For my birthday, I'm gonna…" It's not your turn, shorty. Calm down.
Also, I love cranberry sauce with dressing, and ham with a brown sugar glaze.
I often get called a "scrooge" for complaining about Christmas's annual forced entry into November. Until December 1, I REFUSE to carol, jingle, decorate or participate in any other Christmas activity.
Crock pot Mac and Cheese/Banana split cake
I love Thanksgiving. Let's give its due. I already have my stretchy pants picked out. I am also thinking of marketing my new line of clothing this fall. With paper towel inserst built right into the fronts of the shirts and the thighs of the pants they should be a money maker this Thanksgiving.
I know that kid you were talking about. My first daughter was born toward the end of January when the first of the over due notices come from Christmas bills. Can you say Dollar Store birthday? The other was born on December 1st. She breaks out in hives at the mere mention of "this is for your birthday and Christmas." She would almost rather have 2 dog turds wrapped separately than one decent gift together. I jest, I jest.
Even though I disagree with this comment 100%, the point about the kid at the party is hilarious. Well played.
Jessica: I'm coming for you next week in a guest rebuttal post. I hope FOX News or CNN picks up our blogging spat.
PS: I like sweet potatoes with copious amounts of brown sugar.
Knox: How many points for the use of copious?
Is my Internet personality evolving into one that has constant food debates? Because this pleases me to NO END.
The easy solution is to just not wear pants at Thanksgiving dinner.
You truly get to eat all you want, because everyone is too grossed out to come to the table. Also, you don't have to worry about elastic or waistbands. It's a win-win (well, except for all the grossed-out relatives that end up at Denny's because of their grossed-outness).
And I eat just about anything and everything that I can that doesn't contain the nastiness known to the world as sweet potatoes.
How did I know you were going to be on my grumpy-old-man side, Holl? And so we're clear, that was totally a compliment.
That sounds delicious. I'm going to venture and say this is shaping up to be the tastiest comment thread in the history of comment threads on Knox's blog when he lets me guest post.
I banned the mention of Christmas anything in my house until December 1st. Some may call me a Scrooge for it, but why rush the holidays?!
Thanksgiving definately deserves more honor than its given. The food is amazing, and the atmosphere is almost always more relaxed than Christmas. It seems Christmas tries to require a bit of a holy reverence/respect, while Thanksgiving is mostly focused around indulgence, with a side-helping of thankfulness. Christmas wants me to be sarcasm-free, while Thanksgiving accepts me just as I am.
And Thanksgiving has Turkey AND Ham!
Now why haven't I considered a no-pants stand on Thanksgiving? I must be slipping.
Exactly! We're just giving Thanksgiving the attention it deserves.
And really. Every meal should include turkey and ham.
Not just one football game on T-Giving Jess. Three of them. Three. I may take this view farther than you as someone who has never even put up Christmas lights. I just don't care. And this may sound insane or evil to some people, but now that I live in my new apartment this year I literally won't even put up a Christmas tree. Those things are necessary with kids, but I'm content to not think about any holiday until 2 or 3 days beforehand. Also, you rock. I want to eat food that you make.
Like I told Ricky, the eating starts at precisely 2:00. We have an open door policy at the Buttram household.
And I only ever catch the Cowboys game. Anyone else remember when it was the Cowboys vs. the Redskins every year? Politically incorrectness is so funny.
Can a Bloody Mary count as my favorite Thanksgiving meal? If not, them I'm totally kidding. Kind of.
I really like sweet potatoes.
And HOPEFULLY you won't break into my house and eat ALL my pie after I mention Christmas here.
But this is the reason:
For eight years we've gone to my sister-in-laws for the five days of Thanksgiving (yes, it is not just one day) but she always has all her Xmas decorations up. Always. And Christmas carols are playing. And she's got Christmas puzzles on the table.
She says Thanksgiving is her favorite holiday.
But I think it's because she gets to deck the halls AND eat a crapload.
In her opinion, it's a win win.
Unless someone breaks into your house and eats all your pie.
Okay, so going through this comment thread so far, I've got three houses to hit up for pie. That's a lot of pie.
How about I break into your house and drink all your milk? You know, to wash down all that pie.
I absolutely LOVE, ADORE & EMBRACE Thanksgiving! (I've had a lot of coffee today, so I may over-emote here, but I digress…) Anywho…as a mother of 4 kids, I'm eager to delay the "I want! I want! I want!" version of Christmas for absolutely as long as possible. Thanksgiving is all about what you HAVE and not what you WANT. And any holiday where you have turkey AND ham is blessed in a way words cannot adequately describe, and if it's the spiral glazed ham, so much the better.
I've told my kids if they don't tone it down and let me enjoy Thanksgiving, my next holiday project will be to insure they're going to be more like Jesus this year…in that He got 3 gifts, so I don't know why they should expect any more than that. That seems to have quieted the hoards…
And now, while you question my mothering and quite possible my sanity, I'll be pouring over pumpkin pie recipes…my favorite dish.
I start looking forward to Thanksgiving the day the leftovers run out. Dressing (NOT stuffing, mind you–no bird orifice offerings in this family), oyster pie, turkey, mashed potatoes, corn, green bean casserole. All those carbs in one perfectly acceptable setting followed by the most delightful, if not widely known, pumpkin crisp dessert. Which is like a pumpkin pie, but 100x better. And probably 100x more fattening. But that's the point, isn't it?
Not to mention, it's typically been the only holiday in my family where all 4 kids can make it, along with their kids; there's very little snarkiness but a great deal of laughter, and I am reminded why I actually like my family and enjoy their company. Even when they remind me of embarrassing moments from childhood.
It's a cornucopia of awesomeness, that Thanksgiving. I'm glad to know I am not alone in my adoration.
I was under the impression the 'baby-doll' dress and all others with that raised waist were created for just such occasions.
I love Thanksgiving so much and every year I am aware of the tension between Thanksgiving and Christmas. I mean, how can you compete with Christmas? It makes me want to smack somebody with a drumstick.
I like my Thanksgiving as yellow and brown and tan as humanly possible. So Turkey, Dressing, Mac-n-Cheese, Cornbread, Pecan Pie and Sweet Tea.
Thank you for honoring gluttons everywhere (including this one in Birmingham) with this controversial stand.
Thanksgiving Shaft does not exist in Canada. Our Thanksgiver happens early enough in October that it is not overshadowed by Christmas or Halloween.
THEREFORE:
Thanksgiving in Canada > Thanksgiving in America
and since everyone knows you can cross out things that appear on both sides of an equation…
Canada > America
That's MATH, people.
Clever, Bast.
You do get points for that.