Currently, there is a show on TV that is basically perfect in every way. It’s so perfect that imperfect people like NBC executives think it’s really awesome to take it off the air so drivel like Whitney and Up All Night can be viewed by self-loathing masochists with developmentally stunted senses of humor. (Oh Maya Rudolph making crazy faces?? TELL ME MORE!)
Community, take it or leave it, is more significant in terms of what it means to the larger landscape of television than it is as a weekly television show. Maybe the ratings aren’t anything special, but the innovative way that it manufactures a narrative is infinitely more impactful going forward within the medium than how it fared against Big Bang Theory or CSI-NCIS: Special Hoarders Unit
Much of this is because of structure and execution (Wild West as paintball, zombies, and the My Dinner with Andre spoof leap to mind) but much of it is through character. Simple, yet relentlessly effective and enjoyable characters who motor the engine of the show. Among these characters, Jeff Winger is clearly the Alpha Male whose loins are the wonderful and motherly womb from which the best plots are birthed.
When you consider Jeff Winger and what he represents, his magnetic appeal is eerily similar to another character on a transcendent and generationally important show, Saved By The Bell. Clearly, this character is Mr. Belding.*
*Oh MAN that was a great joke right? I would have LOVED to see the look on your face. Good times.
So we’re clearly talking about Jeff Winger as the evolutionary Zack Morris. But how are they related?
1. An Utter and Absolute Authority Over All Situations
Because both characters are so rich and vibrant, they repeatedly play pivotal parts in most episodes. Jeff has an ability to orate any episode into submission and tie up all loose ends, while Zack could call timeout and freeze time even if he was about to get punched in the face and no one EVER questioned the implications of this on the space time continuum OR the ethical dilemma of a power like that being placed in the hands of someone who is PRETTY void of ethics.
2. Free Love
While Zack is forever and perfectly linked to the female archetype that is Kelly Kapowski, he also did his fair share of dating and spent some measure of romantic time with his castmates Kelly, Lisa, Jessie, Stacy Carosi, some lady in Hawaii and a legion of other minor characters.
Jeff Winger also has managed to make his way through the lady population at Greendale CC. Brita, Annie, and Professor Slater are all love interests Jeff spends a varying amount of time with and while Shirley hasn’t and probably won’t ever be an interest of Jeff’s in terms of traditional romance, I would argue that Jeff’s connection with Shirley in the foosball episode was truer and more profound than any other love connection and thus relevant when discussing Jeff’s relationship to women, but that’s neither here nor there.
The point is, both Zack AND Jeff frequently interact with the various female members of their universe and do so quite successfully.
3. Stylistically Advanced
For Zack it was the Converse shoes and “preppy” clothing. For Jeff, it’s self-tanner, manicures, leather jackets and skinny jeans. The fundamentals of their specific styles my differ, but what is undeniable is how both are clearly portrayed with a superior / distinct sense of style in relation to their peers.
4. Quirky Sidekicks
While Abed is more or less Troy’s sidekick, in terms of Alpha to Beta relationship, Abed is solely and completely Screech to Jeff’s Zack in how he is socially troubled but preemminently intelligent in fringe topics.
5. Evasive Advancement
Jeff’s entire law career is built on the supposition that he authentically obtained an undergraduate degree, which we find out is false.
Similarly, Zack showed an innate talent to skew everything to his advantage to varying degrees of truthiness.Whether it’s trying to connive his way into authoring the school song, cutting his friends out of friendship bracelets, or trying to stick Slater with the nerds in the Marine Corp challenge, Zack has shown a propensity for using people and situations to his advantage basically always.
6. Creepy Authority Figures
While Jeff’s Dean Pelton is superficially creepy, it’s more ok because he’s placed his creepy cards on the table and we more or less know where he stands in his obsession with Jeff and the rest of the study group.
Zack’s Mr. Belding, though, is infinitely more creepy because he concedes nothing in his unceasing interactions with the Bayside Six. Should we automatically assume the worst about Mr. Belding? Certainly not, but if history has taught us anything, it’s that we should always look slightly askance at teachers and school administrators who spend way too much time with students.
Are there any other similarities I missed?






Excellent analysis. I also appreciate the photographic comparison– pre-teen Tamara was all about Zack Morris; adult Tamara doesn't mind the occasional second glance at Jeff Winger. Even if he does have a smaller phone.
Thanks for avoiding the mention of Tori Scott in Zack's flames. She should have no place in the SBTB conversation, and all of those episodes should be placed in a pile with the Miss Bliss ones and burned. In fact, now I feel like you should delete my comment simply because it has the name "Tori Scott" in it. Feel free to, I won't be offended.
You really don't like 'Up All Night?' Have you ever seen it? You and I usually agree on these sorts of things. This vexes me.
I was thinking the same thing. Something about Up All Night is nice and charming, and I'm not even married/a father so I don't know why I like it.
Yeah, seems like you really nailed this one. But Troy is still my favorite.
Knox – I got this one.
This is the curse of Will Arnett's genius. Once you've seen him in Arrested Development, future expectations are (unfairly) high. Combine that with the awesome and relatable subject matter of being new parents, there's almost zero chance Arnett fans' thirst can be quenched.
I'm not proud of this snobbery.
Will Arnett is hilarious. I admit, it's probably not a show I would've started watching if I weren't married, but it's grown on me like "New Girl." It's quirky, much in the same way "30 Rock" is quirky. I like it and do not consider myself a masochist or one owning a developmentally stunted sense of humor.
knox use big words.
Whitney blows.
The Maya Rudolph comment almost knocked me out of my chair!
Arrested Development is the greatest show of all time. "Up All Night" isn't even in the same zip code. I know that. Still a funny show if you give it a chance.
Just my opinion. Maybe I'm wrong and stupid and unaware of what is funny and not funny. I hope this is not the case.
It's me, not you, Kevin. Tyler pretty much nailed it. I REALLY like all the elements because of their past performances (Applegate on Anchorman, Arnett because of AD and Maya because of SNL) but I felt like they are just "Meh." and that makes me mad because I feel like the show could be SO much better.
I have the emotional baggage of a stripper when it comes to TV, Kevin. You need to know that about me.
Nailed it.
I have no words for you, Tamara. Just respect.
Tori Scott doesn't deserve that good of an ending for her archives. They should be buried in a raw sewage pit and lit on fire.
Without question. WITHOUT question.
Up All Night is one big fat disappointment.
It's the time I wanted to be the yearbook photographer and instead got assigned 7th grade section editor. It's the time my sister and I videotaped Model Behavior because, I mean, NSYNC you guys, and getting Justin Timberlake's weirdly falsetto voice and subpar acting ability. It's the combined careers of all the guys in 98 Degrees.
I think Chang is more like Winger's Screech. Winger likes Abed too much for him to be his Screech.
Bah, Up All Night is a huge disappointment. It has brilliant show written all over it but the premise falls flat. I just don't think it's funny at all. And Maya Rudolph's character is annoying.
Interesting. It seems Up All Night is hugely polarizing, but in such a way that people all either hate it or kind of like it but still don't actually love it. I have yet to see anyone express highly positive feelings towards it.
This whole post smacks of brilliance. I'm actually bizarrely drawn to Up All Night. I like all of the components, and I find that the 20 minutes I give to it on a Thursday night doesn't really feel like a waste, but I don't seek it out, and am not enamored by it. I felt the same way about Parks and Rec for the better part of 1 1/2 years, and I think that show is golden now. We'll see what happens.
I would like to see a comparative analysis of Saved By the Bell: The College Years, and Scrubs: New Class. There are striking similarities.
Knox, you win at the Internet. I'm just now watching all of Community on Hulu – just wrapped season 2 today, in fact.
No greater TV has been made than the 3 paintball episodes. The first one, especially, was brilliant.
Community is a perfect show and I'll be all caught up when it comes out of hibernation.